May 04, 2016 (1082 days ago)
0 Subscribers
Colorado, United States
All News by Shadana Sultan

Children of Incarcerated Face Devastating Consequences




By Jim Trotter

Pam’s daughter was 8, her son 4, when she was sentenced to six years in prison in Colorado on a drug possession charge. Pam’s parental rights were terminated. Her kids were placed on a permanency plan, meaning they were tracked for adoption by other parents. All communication between Pam and her children ceased.

“We couldn’t see each other, couldn’t talk to each other,” she said. “I was allowed to write them one letter a year.”

The incarceration of a parent often results in devastating consequences for children left behind. Their lives become harder. Poverty deepens. School problems multiply. Disruption and instability are the new norm for kids already grieving a lost parent.

“Putting a parent in prison is like a nuclear bomb to a child,” said Christie Donner, executive director of the Colorado Criminal Justice Reform Coalition (CCJRC).

There are many such children—in the nation and in Colorado.

A new report by the Annie E. Casey Foundation, which funds the Colorado Children’s Campaign and the annual KIDS COUNT survey, states that 5.1 million children nationally have or have had an incarcerated parent, with 60,000 such kids in Colorado, about 5 percent of all children.

The foundation describes those numbers as conservative. Donner agrees.

“Today, at least 20,000 [Colorado] children have a parent in a state prison,” she said in an interview at her office in the Denver Inner City Parish Community Center on Mariposa Street. “A significantly higher number of children have a parent in and out of county jail.”

The issue is so prevalent that even Sesame Street has a tool kit to guide caregivers in helping young children of the incarcerated.

“It’s gut wrenching,” said Pam, who asked that only her first name be used. She served her entire six years in prison, followed by three years of mandatory parole. “You don’t know what’s going on with your children, whether they’re dead or alive, whether they are safe and happy or being hurt. There’s a lot of turmoil when you have no power to do anything about it. There’s nothing worse than not knowing.”

Having a parent incarcerated is “a stressful, traumatic experience of the same magnitude as abuse, domestic violence and divorce, with a potentially lasting negative impact on a child’s well-being,” said the Casey report.

Just as people of color are extensively overrepresented in the criminal justice system, both nationally and in the state, the burden of incarceration falls heavily on children of color. The Sentencing Project, a Washington D.C.-based criminal justice reform advocacy organization, states that black children are 7.5 times more likely and Latino children are 2.6 times more likely than are white children to have a parent in prison.

Put another way, one in 15 black children, one in 42 Latino children and one in 111 white children had a parent in prison in 2007, according to The Sentencing Project. In Colorado, according to a 2013 analysis by Rocky Mountain PBS News, one in 20 black men were incarcerated, one in 50 Latino men were incarcerated and one in 150 white men were incarcerated.

The Casey Foundation report recommends a collaborative approach to ease the suffering of children of the incarcerated, including supporting children during their parents' incarceration and afterward, helping parents find employment after their release and strengthening communities that are disproportionately affected by incarceration.

As is, the approach in most states, including Colorado, is scattered among community-based organizations. Bridge House in Boulder deals with issues common to ex-offenders—homelessness, unemployment, substance addictions, mental health issues—without exclusively serving those leaving prison. The Mental Health Center of Denver offers a wide range of services to children, parents and other primary caregivers.

Other organizations, including Second Chance Center in Aurora, help ex-offenders as part of their mission. Inside/Out Ministry, also in Aurora, is a faith-based initiative that aims to help ex-offenders through transitional housing and supportive aftercare programs.

Programs for children of the incarcerated are very much “hit and miss,” said CCJRC’s Donner. “Just allowing children to visit their parents can be incredibly difficult. You might have a small church running a bus to the women’s prison in Pueblo, for example.

“Basically, these kids are invisible. We don’t even see them. Acting out in school is seen as a behavioral problem, not as a kid missing his mother.”

Said Pam: “My daughter kept saying, ‘My mother is coming back for me. You can’t put me out for adoption.’ As a result, she was put in 23 different foster homes. She was diagnosed with behavioral problems, put on psychotropic drugs. She is still suffering.”

Pam has now built a career of 10 years with a Denver nonprofit. Over time, she regained custody of both children, who are now adults.

“The best way to help children of the incarcerated is to stop sending so many parents to prison,” said Donner. “Incarceration should only be used when public safety demands it. What if we used a public health model? In public health, the first strategy is prevention.”

Criminal justice reforms are gaining bipartisan traction both in Colorado and nationally. One bill, approved two years ago, allows Coloradans who lost their parental rights while incarcerated to regain them upon leaving prison, if strict conditions are met.

That’s definitely an improvement, according to Pam, who said she was one of only a few parents to regain custody before that law went into effect.

"I don't think that kids or families are ever taken into consideration during sentencing," Pam said. "In a lot of cases, there should be an alternative to prison."

[Back to top]



Reducing Crime: What Works and What Doesn’t




By Kristin Jones

Crime is bad for our health. Think of a rape victim retreating from her friends after being assaulted. Or a parent trying to hold down a job after a child is murdered.

Crime also affects Americans in disparate ways. Poor people are twice as likely to be victims of a violent crime. More young black men die from homicide than any other cause.

So there’s an equity-based case for policymakers to do what they can to reduce crime.

What’s the best way to do that? A new report from the White House Council of Economic Advisors, which provides analysis to the president, reviewed the existing economic literature and came up with some surprising results.

What Doesn’t Work

  • More Incarceration. The economists point out that the U.S. imprisons its residents at a higher rate than all but one other country in the world (the Seychelles, but I digress), and at a rate that’s four times the world average. They cite research showing that incarceration isn’t very effective at reducing crime, and that it becomes less so as more of the population is locked up.
  • Longer Sentences. The longer someone is imprisoned, the more likely they are to commit a crime again once they’re released. At the same time, increasing sentences is not a strong deterrent on crime, according to research cited by the president’s advisors.

Especially when considering the indirect consequences of incarceration—on poverty, employment prospects and the mental health, safety and security of children whose parents are in prison—locking people up fails a cost-benefit analysis from an economic point of view. Essentially, the economists found that this cure is worse than the disease.

What Does Work

  • Education. The case for policies that promote education is very strong, even just from a purely dollars-and-cents perspective. The president’s advisors cite economic research (nine studies in all) that conducts cost-benefit analyses. They include this 2014 study showing that counties that allow kids to drop out of high school at a lower age have higher rates of juvenile crime, and other research showing a strong rate of return on preschool programs and other early-childhood efforts as a way of reducing crime.
  • Policing. Does having more police on the street deter crime? There’s evidence that it does. This 2013 study funded by the National Bureau of Economic Research, for instance, looked at crime data in U.S. cities from 1960 to 2010, and found that police presence reduces violent crime. Another study found that targeting minor crimes—the so-called “broken windows” theory of policing—actually does decrease the occurrence of more serious crimes.
    It’s worth noting, however, that few of these studies consider the damage that can be done by poor policing. The Black Lives Matter movement has brought attention to the disproportionate targeting of people of color—and police violence—that can add to the burden of the same communities that are most impacted by crime.
  • Higher Wages. This is perhaps the most surprising part of the report. The Council of Economic Advisors set two policies against each other: In the first scenario, the United States would increase spending on incarceration by $10 billion, or 12 percent. This would reduce the crime rate by an estimated 1 to 4 percent. At best, the policy would benefit us by reducing crime to the tune of $1 billion; at worst, it would cost us $8 billion.
    By contrast, raising the federal minimum wage from $7.25 an hour to $12 by 2020 would likely reduce crime by 3 to 5 percent, and reap a reward of $8 billion to $17 billion. By their estimate, lifting up those at the bottom would leave us all wealthier and safer.

Click here to read the full report.

[Back to top]

Other News in this Category
City and County of Denver announced the move of the Airport Concessions Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (ACDBE) program from the Denver Office of Economic Development’s Division of Small Business Opportunity (DSBO) to Denver International Airport (DEN). (read more)
67 days ago · From Shadana Sultan
Join RMICC in welcoming new Voting Board Member, Kelly Reyos (Ute Indian Tribe). (read more)
86 days ago · From Shadana Sultan
Join RMICC in welcoming new Voting Board Member, Joel Smith, member of Caddo Nation and Sr VP/Chief Credit Officer of Native American Bank. (read more)
88 days ago · From Shadana Sultan
An enrolled member of the Delaware Tribe of Indians and the Cherokee Nation of Oklahoma, Ms. Compton holds a J.D. from the University of Denver, Sturm College of Law, and a B.A. from the College of the Holy Cross. (read more)
89 days ago · From Shadana Sultan

Back to Top